A few thoughts on alternative medicine in a western world

So there was this article in the Chicago Tribune on Sunday, Federal center pays good money for suspect medicine

It is about how much money is spent researching the efficacy of non-bio based therapies, including acupuncture, massage, energy healing, prayer, etc.

My issue isn't so much about people that say these forms of medicine/healing are bogus or that we shouldn't be spending money on this. My issue is trying to fit one paradigm into another.

Bio-medicine is the only medicine that acts as if each human body is exactly the same, and that all treatments can be the same. Most alternative forms of medicine, including acupuncture, are case specific.

Everyone's body, and their illness/symptoms, are unique. Perhaps not in presentation, but in the root cause, absolutely.

Example.

Two people come in with Migraine headaches. One person's migraine headache stems from an imbalance of Qi Stagnation, the other client's root cause is a Kidney Deficiency.

They are treated VERY differently. And when the proper root cause is addressed, the symptom (Migraine headache) is resolved, usually for good.

I see the difficulty in testing to 'prove' efficacy. Many many acupuncturists want it proven. I always say, 'well, it's been here for over 2500 years, so something must be working.'

When one modality (i.e., acupuncture) does not fit into the construct of a different modality (i.e., bio-medicine) why would we think we could test for the first modality within the constructs of the second?

We will probably continue to shove that square peg into the round hole for awhile. I am not surprised it doesn't work.

Enjoy your day, be well, smile often.

First Magnolia House Newsletter and Gift Certificates

The first Magnolia House newsletter came out the other day. If you missed it, you can check it out online here.